top of page

FUN! Instead of Clapping, This Audience Member Gave a Thumbs Up After Every Song

  • Writer: Broadway Beat
    Broadway Beat
  • Jan 14
  • 2 min read

Updated: Feb 25

by Mike Abrams. @TheWrongCatDied.


NEW YORK, NY  -  Spring break chaperone and self-described “quiet midwesterner” Tom Bryant disrupted a Saturday matinee of & Juliet when instead of applauding, he simply offered a single thumbs up after every musical number.


"I just wanted the cast members to know that I hear them, I see them, and I appreciate their performances," stated Bryant, who held the gesture just below shoulder level to not disrupt the view of the people behind him. "Clapping is so aggressive and noisy. A thumbs up is personal. It shows them that we bonded in the magic of live theatre. The Bon Jovi song to end act one was so good I considered giving snaps, but ended up sharing a rare double thumbs up instead.”


Johanna Furphy, who was performing as Anne that afternoon, found the gesture less supportive and deeply unsettling.


"It felt like psychological warfare," noted Furphy, who claimed she could see Bryant’s thumb glowing in the reflection of the stage lights. "Usually you ride the wave of applause. But every time the lights went down there was just this guy locking eyes with me and thrusting his thumb into the air like a Roman Emperor deciding if I should live or die. Did he even like the show?"


Trisha McConnell, a local theatregoer sitting directly next to Bryant, also expressed confusion regarding his silent gesture.


"I thought maybe he had a hand injury, but then I saw him open a bag of Skittles with extreme dexterity during the quiet part of 'De Bois Band'," stated McConnell as she realized she should have also bought Skittles. "He kept leaning over to me and whispering 'that was a solid yes from me' while nodding. It was the longest two hours and forty minutes of my life."


Bryant claimed he has also purchased tickets for CATS: The Jellicle Ball, where he plans to replace the standing ovation with a "casual finger gun and a wink" - a reference to absolutely nothing in the show.

 
 
 

2 Comments


Champa Biswas
Champa Biswas
Feb 27

srd status check lets you track the progress of your sassa r350 r370 grant application online. it shows whether your application is approved, pending, declined, or paid. you can also see your payment date, update banking details, and check reasons for rejection. regular checks help you stay informed about monthly approvals, delays, or issues. it allows you to take quick action if needed, such as reapplying or submitting an appeal. you only need your south african id number and registered phone number to access your status.

Like

Elliott Lawery
Elliott Lawery
Feb 27

I just read this post about the audience member giving a thumbs up and it really made me think about how little moments like that can show genuine appreciation for live performance. I’ve been working on an assignment about event atmosphere and audience interaction, and sometimes I struggle to organize all my ideas into clear writing that actually flows. That’s why I needed some Native Assignment Help  getting my thoughts together and explaining them well isn’t always easy. This article gave me real examples and inspiration that helped me see how to describe audience reactions better in my own work, which made writing my piece feel more manageable.

Like
bottom of page